Identity and Ideology vis-à-vis Palestine

Over the past century, not only have Palestinians andwith its core historical and religious elements,
Zionists fought on Palestine’s terrain of battle,constitutes a potential deal-breaker. Outside the
but so have Turks, British and Jordanians. Each hasimmediate Israeli-Palestinian orbit, the Jerusalem
had reason to invest itself in the region.Question is on the lips of, among others, Moroccans,
Whether it was early-twentieth-century fadingIraqis, Iranians and Turks, to say nothing of “the
Ottoman imperial intent, energetic colonialism in theTrio”—Jordan, Egypt and Saudi Arabia—and
case of the British Mandate (1922–1948), the de“the Quartet”—the United Nations, the
facto division of land between Israel and JordanUnited States, the European Union and Russia.
under their 1948 armistice agreement, or IsraeliMedieval Christians placed the city at the center of
retention of the territorial spoils of the 1967 war,their spiritual lives because the Roman Catholic and
each power has expressed aspects of its ownOrthodox churches sanctified physical Jerusalem. As a
identity and ideology vis-à-vis Palestine.result, and in the absence of geographic knowledge
The Palestinians still seek to express their identity byand appropriate technology, their maps showed
establishing a state where international justice,Jerusalem at the center of the globe. A separate,
recognition of their historic property claims andearlier tradition also named it the omphalos, or navel,
accommodation of some refugees’ right ofof the world, and yet another, the birthplace of the
return can be achieved. But their conflict with thecosmos.
Israelis has now become centered on one essentialMirroring these conceptions in some ways, the
square kilometer—the Old City ofmodern world seems to have returned to such
Jerusalem—within which lie the ancient symbolsimages, and Jerusalem has become once more the
and trophies of these now opposing identities.center of the world’s attention (to be
Reserved for final-status negotiations, Jerusalem,continued).